|
Kashmir and Neighbors |
Violence in KashmirFanning the Flames | Violence in Kashmir | The Retreat of the Rebellion The circumstances in late 1989 and the beginning of 1990 transformed Kashmir into a dreamboat for Pakistan, which was interested in seeing political instability in these neighboring lands since 1947. The mishandling of the situation by the Indian authorities, such as the stoppage of the democratic process in Kashmir and the police inability to respond by more peaceful means when necessary, created room for Pakistani interference. The militants changed the names of some roads, and reset their watches in accordance with Pakistan standard time. When the state of affairs were conducive to Pakistan’s involvement, the pro-Pakistan fundamentalist leagues did not yet enjoy as much support as the JKLF, the leading separatist movement in the whole country. The members of an all-party delegation, including the Deputy Prime Minster (Devi Lal), two cabinet ministers (George Fernandes and Dinesh Goswami) and a former Prime Minister (Rajiv Gandhi), visited Srinagar (9 March) with the best of intentions but were appalled to hear the sweeping slogans of “azadi” (freedom) and witness the widespread tension in the city. While the governor, who was not in Srinagar during these dramatic events, and could not meet the delegation at the airport, the staff of the hotel that hosted the leaders ironically joined the anti-Indian demonstrations. The delegation had to return to New Delhi the next morning leaving behind only George Fernandes who had just been appointed as the Cabinet Minister for Kashmir Affairs in addition to his portfolio for Railways. While there are more killings of the Indian Pandits and demonstrations. it was surprising that the governor could continue to stay in Jammu. Extensive demonstrations frightened the Pandits, who thought that the mobs expected them either to join them or quit the Valley. The imposing processions on the one hand, and the sluggishness of the government on the other seemed to register in the minds of many as though “independence” had really dawned. |
Following
Governor Jagmohan’s participation in a meeting of the Cabinet
Committee on Political Affairs (CCPA) in New Delhi, and the processions at Rawalpur and Zakura
where the police had fired at the unarmed crowds, all parades and
pickets, no matter what the occasion or source, were banned. The
authorities had initially refrained from taking note of rallies that
eventually gathered momentum, and now chose to prohibit them all when
they seemed to have established roots. Both phases of official attitude
offered opportunities to Pakistan to promote its political and material
support to the terrorist-secessionist forces in Kashmir. The
difficulties encountered in efforts to return to normality were in part
created by this entrenched external dimension, explainable by successive
ill considered local policies as much as Pakistan’s motives. The
whole Srinagar community suffered unreasonable hardship when Governor
Jagmohan imposed an indefinite curfew immediately after the dead bodies
of the General Manager of the Hinduism Machine Tools Factory (H.L. Khera)
and the Vice Chancellor of the Kashmir University (Musheer-ul Haq) were
dumped somewhere near the Police Control Room (9 April). Although a
decision for a curfew may at times show governmental sense of purpose
and firmness, the people, whose homes were searched, felt nevertheless
foreigners in their own land while the terrorists were still able to
murder (1 May) an inspector of police (C.L. Shalla) and a prominent
religious leader (Maulwi Farroq). When the police opened fire and killed
many of the mourners, some of whom might have behaved in an unruly
fashion during the funeral procession of the assassinated Islamic doyen
who enjoyed a large following, an invaluable opportunity to alienate the
people from the militants slipped out of the hands of the authorities.
The panic and the over action of the police offered the killers of the
religious leader instead another chance to perpetuate and spread
terrorism. Moreover, although this confrontation between the security
forces and the public was no ordinary affair, the Police Control Room
that received no report about it and the governor whose information came
from the same source denied that the bloody tragedy had ever occurred.
Nevertheless, the people blamed the governor, who was called to New
Delhi and who never returned to Srinagar. Girish C. Saxena, an
experienced bureaucrat who succeeded Jagmohan, believed in utmost
secrecy to the extent of declining to share information even with his
closest associates. Soon, senior civil servants publicly differed with
the new governor, and the strike of the state government employees,
supported even by the National Conference leaders, lasted for two-and- a
half months and was badly handled by the government. Moreover, every
time the administration changed in New Delhi, the newcomers felt free to
criticize the previous leadership and unintentionally encouraged
anti-union forces. The Kashmir issue was skipping from one phase to
another leaving behind slayings, hangings, firings, searches and
arrests, whose culprits on both sides largely escaped punishment. In any
case, with the removal of Jagmohan, it was no longer necessary to have a
separate Cabinet Minister for Kashmir Affairs. Under
the circumstances, Pakistan continued to be the unmistakable
“winner”. The JKLF was the main “independence” movement in the
initial period of the disturbances. There were other pro-independence
groups were mostly later additions. Amanullah Khan, one of the leaders
of the JKLF, was based in Pakistan from where he planned and handled the
operations. Like all pro-independence groups who went along with
Pakistan because India was the common enemy and the neighboring Muslim
state provided various kinds of material assistance, Amanullah Khan of
the JKLF appreciated the value of correct relations with groups such as
the Hizb-ul Mujahiddeen and the Jamaat-e Islami, both of which
consistently championed accession to Pakistan. Hizbullah Islamia
Jamhooria, which came into focus in 1989, stated that armed attacks on
the security forces would continue until Kashmir abandoned the Indian
Union. In
addition to the cliques and formations mentioned above, India’s neighbor
Pakistan curtailed its material support to the JKLF and
channeled its subsidies to a number of Islamicist combative groups. In
the mid-1990s, there were some forty terrorist organizations involved in
intimidation, shock, and slaughter. Some of them, such as the People’s
League, upheld a merger with Pakistan but did not oppose independence.
Their multiplicity enabled the organizers, local and foreign, to
manipulate the surviving ones if some others proved to be inoperative on
account of arrests or closures. |
|
It is not surprising that the number of incidents in 1989 (2154) almost doubled in 1990 (3905)-only to decline in 1991(3122). Terrorism was better organized and progressively funded and nourished from abroad, but the popular outcry began to wane. The terrorists now possessed sophisticated weapons and were better trained but were losing touch with the exhausted public. Only a year ago, the popular upsurge bordered on the maximum. The balance was now reversed. Forceful terrorist networks needed lively popular support to achieve the goal of secession. Pakistan had to revive what was now missing-the people’s backing. The year 1991 did not bring popular support but disagreements and showdowns among the militants. For instance, a rival group killed a district (Balakot) chief (Muhammad Akbar Zargar) of the Muslim Mujahideen. Although the abduction of the daughter (Nathida Imtiaz) of the National Conference leader Professor Saifuddin Soz secured the release (8 March)[1] of a jailed militant, and the murder of two intellectuals (the veteran freedom-fighter A.S. Ranjoor and the Urdu daily Al-Safa’s editor M.S. Vakil) went unpunished, the Jammu and Kashmir Students’ Liberation Front (JKSLF) appealed to the pro-Pakistani groups to cease illegal operations. While Islamabad diverted more funds and arms to pro-Pakistan factions, there were growing symptoms of disillusionment among the people, who now yearned for a return to normality; that is, an end to violence, and a flow of income from tourism. When the Kashmiri authorities decided to reactivate tourism in the Valley, pro-Pakistani militants kidnapped two Swedish engineers employed at the Uri Hydro-Power Project, seven Israeli tourists and a Dutch citizen. With the angry crowds shouting anti-Pakistan slogans, the tide was turning against terrorism and foreign intervention for the first time since the year 1988. The JKLF had to also condemn the abduction of foreign visitors. This new trend did not restrain all of the hardliners, some of whom burnt to death (23 June) three Hindus and tied explosives to the bodies of two Muslims. Although the kidnapping (28 June) of a senior executive of the Indian Oil Corporation (K. Doraiswamy) by the Ikhwan-ul Muslimeen was unpopular with the masses, the militants secured the release of their colleagues including the terrorist (Javed Shalla) accused of the murder of an industrialist and a university administrator. The authorities could not capitalize on the acknowledged deception of the masses even when the Valley residents were weary of unending abductions and bloody rivalries between the militant groups. The successful rescue (18 October) of the Wakholl couple, the wife being a former Tourism Minister in the J&K government, was a victory for the security forces.[2] The
predicament somewhat changed for the better when the 1991 elections
brought the Narasimha Rao government to power in New Delhi, the slight
switch becoming more visible towards the end of the year. The number of
incidents declined considerably, and the security forces killed 17 and
captured 31 militants in October 1991 alone. As it frequently happens
with a change of government, the newcomers soon blamed their
predecessors for failures and made repeated statements that things were
improving rapidly. This charge and challenge once more helped the
militants to make another comeback. Even the State Director of Police
J.N. Saxena was among those injured when a bomb exploded (24 January
1992) in the main security office.[3]
The militants were still able to kidnap 64 persons in the first three
months of 1992. This temporary upward trend encouraged some Pakistani
sponsors to suggest a mass crossing of the Line of Actual Control. Since
Pakistan favoured Hizb-ul Mujahideen more than the other analogous
organizations, the JKLF supported the idea to outbid its rivals. Lending
an ear to intervened and frustrated the border violations at the last
moment. With
the year 1992 approaching its end, the demolition of the Babri Masjid at
Ayodhya, which sent an exaggerated message all over the world that
secularism in India was giving way to an extremist Hindu ideology,
helped transform the semi-sleeping
monster of communalism into an uncontrollable epidemic in the streets.
The militants in Kashmir damaged a number of Hindu temples. The Rao
government’s partial response to strong criticism for its conduct
during the riots in the aftermath of the Ayodhya affair was the
appointment of a special Minster of Internal Security (Rajesh Pilot) to
deal exclusively with Kashmir. Not only was this commissioning a
repetition of the former superficial Fernandes experience, it
corresponded to the reappointment of General K.V. Krishna Rao to
governorship replacing G.C. Saxena. While these assignments were
interpreted as part of a softer line policy, Dr. A. A. Guru, known for his close
relations with the JKLF and also for his soft line, was
kidnapped by the militants (31 March) and found dead the next day. April
1993 was one of the worst months in the history of terrorism in Kashmir.
Not only did 124 persons lose their lives in just three days, but a
false rumour that a constable died in army custody caused an angry
police procession, after which twenty officers were dismissed for their
role in showing disobedience. April
1993 also witnessed waves of foreign Muslim mercenaries from
Afghanistan, Morocco, Saudi Arabia and Sudan coming to the Valley and to
the Doda district, where slightly over 40% of the population are Hindus.
Reinforced by such well-trained people, the militants established
“liberated areas” in parts of Srinagar, Anantnag and Baramulla,
targetted checkposts and patrol units, and held some abducted persons
(for instance, the former Bihar legislator P.K. Sinha) for almost a
year. Since
1993 the terrorists have been using more sophisticated weapons such as
air-to-ground rockets, artillery shells, high-velocity grenades,
long-range wireless sets, pen pistols, and telescope-fitted sniper
rifles. Even the Secretariat building in Srinagar, which lasted for
thirty-two days (15 October-16 November),[4]
and managed to hold a public exhibition of some of their sophisticated
weaponry near a police picket. Both the terrorists and the officials had
drawn lessons from the
Golden Temple catastrophe in Punjab. The militants at Hazratbal
surrendered in the end. The
year 1994 saw 85 rocket attacks, 370 kidnappings, 4,000 arrests, and
2,500 dead.[5]The
great majority of the last mentioned were militants. The security forces
successfully sealed the border along the LAC. New Delhi invited some
foreign diplomats and the International Red Cross to visit the Valley.
1995 witnessed more frequent use of remote control devices to detonate
explosives, one of which killed (20 March) a Brigade Commander of the
Army (V.Gopal Sheridharan). [6]
It also marked the possession (December 1994-May 1995) by the Harkat-ul
Ansar militants of the shrine of the Sufi saint Nooruddin Noorani at
Charar-e Sharif near Srinagar. Harkat-ul Ansar was born out of the
merger of two Pakistani political activist movements, and financed
mainly by Saudi Arabia and some other Arab Gulf countries. They all
sought Kashmir’s accession to Pakistan. Harkat-ul Ansar had several
thousand armed men in the Pakistani-held part of Kashmir. The militants
under Mast Gul, who killed two securtiy officers for provocation,
started a fire in the shrine of this exalted Kashmiri saint. While Mast
Gul escaped to Pakistan to received a hero’s welcome there , it became
obvious that, after the experience in Punjab, the militants preferred
to use shrines to bring about confrontations with the authorities. The
capture of a handful of militants not being worth the devastation of a
shrine, it could be difficult to dislodge them. The rest of the year saw
the kidnapping of four foreign tourists, four local journalists, sixteen
forestry technicians and ten others, three of whom were killed. |
|
The
total number of incidents of terrorist violence in J&K in the last
decade (1998 –June 1999)[7]
is 45,852 while about a quarter (11,240) of them are related to
explosion and arson. The total number of killings in terrorist violence
for the same period is no less than 21,039, about a third (7,672) being
Muslims, the latter being more than the Hindus killed (958), some
government officials (372), politicians (153) and top political leaders
(15). There have been 3,179 cases of kidnappings, the whereabouts of 258
persons being still unknown but 1,222 put on file as killed. Kidnapped
individuals include government officials (308), politicians (129), and
foreigners (20). Although only a fractions of cases of extortion and
lootings are reported to the authorities an account of fear, the number
of registered incidents stand at 810, and the amount robbed adds up to
108, 905, 286 rupees. Total incidents of destruction of property by
militants add up to 4,974. A great deal of weapons were recovered from
militants, including grenades (35,163), grenade launchers (341),
explosives (21, 476 kg.), AK series rifles (20,476), snipers (305),
pistols (8,179), mines (5,683), rockets (3,106), bombs (1,972), rocket
boosters (1,577), rocket launchers (903), guns (1,603), machine guns
(1,135), and mortars (127). Violence
perpetrated by terrorists included abductions and killings of targeted prominent
personalities, brutalities inflicted on innocent persons,
atrocities on women, children, Christian missionary institutions and
foreign nationals, attacks on Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs and members of the
press, robberies, extortions, destruction of property and looting.
Torture followed kidnappings, with instances sof gouging out of eyes,
breaking of limbs, and slitting of throats until the victims bleed to
death. In one incident a terrorist reportedly ate a bit of the victim's flesh. Extortions were as rampant as the rape of women. The
lust turned lethal with the discovery of AIDS among some mercenaries.
Such distressing stories are discernible in almost every corner of
J&K embroiling all spheres and professions, in fact all walks of
life, and modifying in the process the entire political life of the
land. The incidents occurred in the towns and villages of Srinagar,
Anantnag, Baramulla, Doda, Jammu, Kupwara, Poonch, Pulwana, and Rajouri.
Instances of open public anger against militant actions have to be
mentioned in this description of atrocities against different sections
of society. In
the last decade, there have been close to 200 incidents in which
prominent personalities were murdered or attakced. Among them were
ex-ministers (Abd-ul Jabbar, Hissam-ud Din, Ghulam Hassan Shah), editors
of daily newspapers, professors (Abd-ul Ahad Wani, Kundan Lal,
Musheer-ul Haq), politicians, professionals, businessmen, human rights
activists (H.N. Wanchoo), prominent writers, and poets (Ahmed Din
Mushtaq, Nazir Ahmed Hafiz). For instance, Dr. Rubaiya Sayeed, the
daughter of the then Union Home Minister, was carried off at gun point.
Professor Musheer-ul Haq was kidnapped from the Kashmir University
campus and shot dead. Professor K.L. Ganjoo, from the Wadoora
Agriculture College, was killed on the river bank. The principal of the
(S.S.M) Polytechnic College was abduced, and Professor M.A. Azhari
from Kashmir University shot at. The mutilated body of Jalil Indrabi,
the Chairman of the Kashmir Commission of Jurists, was recovered from
the River Jhelum at Rajbagh. Professor Yusuf-ul Umar, the President of
the Iqbal Memorial Trust, was shot at and injured. Even Dr. Farooq
Abdullah, several times Chief Minister of J&K, was attacked (in
Rajouri on 9 December 1995), and an explosion occurred in the building
premises of Dr. A.M. Mattoo, the brother-in-law of Dr. Abdullah. Innocent
people were found hanging from trees, ailing men shot dead in hospitals
where they were undergoing treatment, headless bodies with limbs chopped
off recovered from rivers, and others dragged from their homes, tortured
and slain. Some civilians lost their lives in cross fire from rival
militant groups. Many women children were not spared. While talking
about virginity and the purdah,[8]
the militants displayed no esteem for women. Many maidens and spouses,
mostly Muslim, were carried off, tormented in various ways, decapitated,
and sexually abused. Some were shot at work places or inside their own
homes or burnt to death. Gunmen frequently intruded into private houses
and liquidated the whole family including the woman folk and infants.
Thugs frequently looted household articles, and at times, entered
private homes to open indiscriminate fire or hurl a grenade into the
dwellings. The Muslim Kashmiri desperados slices a woman’s breast
before shooting her (in Sajithana Mandi, Rajouri on 13 March 1998), and
slit the throat of another (in Phagla Surankote, Poonch on 19 June 1998). Some
children were killed on a school compound, and others injured by
antipersonnel mines. There were grenade attacks on school buses (in
Pulwana on 5 January 1998). More than thirty youngsters were harmed in
the Maulana Azad Stadium in Jammu (20 January 1998) when stormier caused
three explosions during the Republic Day celebrations. Deranged
cutthroats chopped the nose and ears of children before killing them (in
Bhatadurian, Poonch on 2 March 1998). A brutal attack on a marriage
party (in Doda on 19 June 1998) killed 26 Hindus.[9]
The Lassa Sheikh family lost 19 of its members, the killers not moved to
compassion even before minors (in Poonch on 3 August 1998). Explosions
were aimed at causing the closure of the Christian missionary schools in
Srinagar. The hostel building of the Bisco Memorial School, among others
was set on fire, an attempt was made to set ablaze the Burn Hall School,
affiliated with the local Catholic mission, and an explosion occurred
near the Miss Melanson Girls’ School. American, British, Dutch,
French, German, Israeli, Norwegian, and Swedish tourists were abducted,
and the bullet-ridden bodies of some of them were later recovered. On several occasions, the hunters intruded into the J&K Bank, the Central Cooperative Bank, the Rural Development Bank and others to loot money. They attacked post offices and vanished with the cash. They ransacked shops, private homes and mosques and decamped with the contents of the money chests. They carried away, not only gold ornaments and jewellery, but even stone idols of Hindu deities from local temples. At times, armed militants cordoned off the village (in Sangra, Doda on 17 May 1995) and looted all Hindu houses or took away hundreds trucks, ambulances, oil tankers and scooters. Some of these vehicles were loaded with merchandise such as timber, cement, copper, steel rods, silk fabrics, and coal or food like rice, sugar, fruit and the like. [1] The Hindu, Madras, 9 March 1991, [2] Ibid., 19 October 1991, [3] Ibid., 25 January 1992, [4] “Hazratbal Siege Ends in
Surrender”, The Times of India, New Delhi, 17 November
1993, Editorial (“Truimph of Patience”): “The peaceful end of
the Hazratbal crisis is a matter of great relief, not only because
of the militants’ tame surrender, but also because of its
long-term impact may well resemble that of the celebrated “Black
Thunder” denouement in Punjab which severely demoralized the
insurgents there. In Kashmir, too, it will obiviously take some time
for the terrorists and their patrons in Pakistan to overcome the
effect of the supine manner in which the rebels trooped out of the
shrine at the dead of night, belying all their
all their dire threats including that of blowing it up… [T]he
holy relic has not been harmed in any way…”Ibid.,., [5] A 16-year old [6] The Hindu, Madras, 21 March 1995, [7] Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, Profile of Terrorist Violence in Jammu and Kashmir: June 1999, New Delhi, 1999, [8] A famous work on puradah, originally published in 1939 and reprinted several times. Maulana AbdulA’la Maududi, Purdah and the Status of Woman in Islam, Lahore, Islamic Publications Ltd., 1979. [9] The Hindu, Madras, 20 June 1998, |
|