India Intelligence Report

 

 

 ICDS Needs Overhaul

  Concern over poor implementation of Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS) has prompted Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to write to all States and Union Territories asking them to set up a process of dealing with child development.
 

 

Hot Topics

AEC Chairman Guarded on Nuke Deal
Indo-Russia Trade Needs Addressing
China Tries to Curb Export Growth
UK Interests in Indian Agriculture
ICDS Needs Overhaul
India in New Security Block

 

Other Stories

AEC Chairman Guarded on Nuke Deal
China Tries to Curb Export Growth
India in New Security Block
Indo-Russia Trade Needs Addressing
UK Interests in Indian Agriculture
   

Concern over poor implementation of Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS) has prompted Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to write to all States and Union Territories asking them to set up a process of dealing with child development. For a man who is usually very balanced, Singh asked for an institutionalized review process to exclusively deal with ICDS, Singh asked states to focus on minority communities and Scheduled Castes and Tribes. With key state level elections around the corner, many skeptics are questioning the motives of the letter.

In his letter, Singh specifically pointed out a qualitative drop in the Focus on Children Under Six program and in violation of Supreme Court judgments that mandated such programs. Citing the National Family Health Survey, Singh warned of “strong evidence that the programme has not led to any substantial improvement in the nutritional status of children under six.” He bemoaned that India’s “rate of under-nutrition in this age group remains one of the highest in the world.” Further, he pointed out that the “immunization status under the ICDS continues to be poor” and as a result 11 crore children out of a total of 16 crore in the 0-6 age group are not reached. He implored the Chief Ministers to initiate “urgent action.”

Idealistically, Singh said that he believes that the problem can be solved through “political will, decentralised monitoring and meticulous attention to day-to-day operational issues” failing which “problems like irregular functioning of anganwadi centres, inability to provide hot, cooked food, and leakage of food material meant for infants will persist." Commending Tamil Nadu for empowering its Panchayat and urban local institutions, Singh asked all states to follow this model and make line officials accountable for their actions. If this is not done, he said that the 11th Plan objectives of “univeralisation with quality” cannot be achieved.

However sincere, the letter itself is inadequate and has many inbuilt problems. Firstly, it divides the nation by religion and castes when most of the children who are out of the ambit of the program clearly span all groups. Secondly, the letter merely pleads for action and does not provide leadership in terms of setting targets or goals for others to follow. Thirdly, while it asks Chief Ministers to seek accountability of line officials, it does not ask for political accountability. Fourthly, the letter does not ask for proper financial and accounting validation, oversight, consequences, or incentives for states to adhere.

Most of the money spent in India is siphoned at various levels and mostly by the political class. Given this situation, sending a mere letter without leadership sounds more like a public relations exercise with an eye on upcoming elections in many key states. Petty considerations that one hopes that the Prime Minister will not be slave to.